Showing posts with label self. Show all posts
Showing posts with label self. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

Measuring the self over time

The self isn’t a persistent thing. It fades in and out of existence, conjured by a biological machine like the stale image from an old slide projector. It comes and goes, not with a regular ebb and flow like the tide, but erratically, motivated by some external factors which we must come to understand. With its arrhythmic beat we pulse in and out of existence. Cogito ergo sum, “I think, therefore I am”, but what then are we for the moment when we thought not?

Indeed, the self fades in and out of existence. Deindividuation is one way of it—to relax the burden of selfhood and exist momentarily as part of a whole. This is what occurs within the crucible of the mosh pit, where under the intense heat of molten flesh, fire of rage and thunder of blast beats, the self all but disappears. No self-centered thoughts like behavioral propriety, no thoughts of what others will say, no plans for the future, no wrangling over the past. No thoughts of bills to pay, papers to write, careers to make, statuses to update, dates to keep: Only the most vague sense of right now. Mosh, push, shove, survive, dance, and howl in Bacchic annihilation.

My heart is pounding out of my chest, 180 BPM. Throat is raw and lungs about to burst. The blast beat fades into a melodic transition. The weak signal from the self slowly emerges—pulling me back from the edge of oblivion. Retreat. Breathe. Maintain.

Safely out of the pit, I become aware of myself again. The burning pain in my chest, and a certain surprise at my recklessness. I see the girl I was flirting with before. There’s another guy she’s talking to. Who is he? Is he more impressive than I am? What does she think of me? Where do I stand? Jealously, longing, anxiety, anger, resentment, my Machiavellian mind is assessing the situation, estimating probabilities, and calculating a course of action. I have become fully self-conscious.

Where and when does the self disappear? This may be a key to understanding what we really are. Therefore, we must develop a means to measure the self. Observe the dynamic correlation between consciousness interacting with time. Understand this mysteriously evolving relationship, a temporal function, but what else? Evolutionary theory suggests thatthe ‘what else’ is a function of selection pressures. The self is an adaption that favored survival and reproduction under a certain, but ultimately unknowable, set of circumstances. Yett we can conjecture, and not altogether ignorantly. The self was called upon when I was preoccupied with the girl from the dance floor, but not when I was in battle. Within the battle I was gone. My body was on its own, running an emergency, autonomous program called berzerker rage. Who was around me didn’t matter. The berzerker has no need of nuanced social distinctions. In the presence of a mate, social distinction is paramount; n-player multidyadic chess. Everybody is against everybody, but we are all locked in varying degrees of interdependence. Men and women can’t mate without one another and men can’t fight alone. To do this, nature packed the human body plan with three and a half pounds of biological cognition, tuned to optimize an expected payoff across countess simultaneous and parallel utility functions; calculations far too complex for any computer of my day.

But the human brain is more than an information-computational system, it’s a hybrid dynamical-system with both logical and mechanical hardwiring. We can solve problems by thinking about them, or rely on essentially mechanical processes requiring virtually no computation. Computation is costly and isn’t always necessary. When instinct is enough, let the conscious mind rest. In the crucible of battle, the self will have nothing of the blood and the death and the gore, and reason it’s way out the door! No, the self doesn’t get to play then; s/he sits this one out.

Thursday, May 5, 2011

A non-Western conception of Self

I will share a bit of personal experience that may help to elucidate a conception of the Self different from one we, as occidentals, tend to hold. I regularly engage in meditation. Specifically, I practice Buddhist meditation. Buddhism, in my opinion, is fundamentally concerned with the experience of consciousness. While pain is an inevitable consequence of life, Buddhists hold that suffering isn't. Suffering is an outcome arising from a psychological attachment between the 'self' and the pain. E.g. "I am hurting", "I am dying". Language here is somewhat ineffective, but they mean to describe a kind of unity, or oneness between the experience and the self, where selfhood, or consciousness, is constituted/indiscernible by the experience. Through rigorous practice, Buddhists believe that the various 'attachments' between the self and experience (several such attachments are usually enumerated) can be severed. Contrary to the Western expectation, this does not "liberate" the soul/mind/self, it obliterates it. Once these attachments to experience are broken, the mind is induced to a seemingly untenable condition of existence and non-existence. This they call 'sunyata'. My own personal trials with meditation suggests a certain plausibility to this view.

Here is a little anecdotal example: Imagine you're sitting on a bench in a park, when an attractive woman (or man) just your type takes a seat at the other end. Your heart beat accelerates, fingertips moisten--all sorts of physiological responses to her arrival. As you know, these physiological changes generally occur below the "level of conscious awareness". Consciously, you feel nervous, excited, and giddy like a school boy (girl). You actually feel somehow drawn to her physically, like something invisible tugging at your insides in her direction. "I like her!," you exclaim to yourself in an internal monologue. You're paralyzed, but hyper-focused on these feelings. Whatever you were thinking about is gone, intellect is debilitated, "hello" is at the tip of your tongue, but you cannot speak. From a Buddhist's perspective, your psychological attachment allowed an external event to transmit and exert a force upon your mind, momentarily generating chaos.

Richard Dawkins, of course, would tell you that these are your genes taking control of you for their own selfish purposes. You're being manipulated like a marionette on endocrinary strings to mate with this fit and fertile female. The genetic lingo is new, but more or less this is what Western philosophers have called 'passions', and have invented various philosophies and religions with the notion of mastering them, subjugating them to the rational mind and thereby restoring this drooling schoolboy to his 'free will'. Buddhism, I think, may be closer to Dawkins in that they see such 'passions' as an inescapable aspect of our nature. We can no more subjugate the passions than we can our need for oxygen or nourishment. But we can be aware of them, and their power over us understood as an external force. This is called 'mindfulness', and is the basic form of meditation, involving slow, methodical, and non-judgmental reflection on sensations from the body. One by one, each sensation is bracketed off as separate from the mind, a force acting on it, not out of it, and summarily released back to the ether from which it came. Contrary to the Westerns, when the less sensation is externalised there is nothing left: no purified soul-mind. Just sunyata, or emptiness.

In sum, I've explored some possible insights into a view of consciousness inspired by Buddhist philosophy and practice, as well as by natural philosophy. The position is that what we call 'consciousness' is really just a kind of visuo-linguistic account of the things we're doing and an essentially arbitrary sense of why (e.g., "I like her!"). It is such, presumably, because it served some adaptive function that was especially useful for a highly-social, savanna primate. Had circumstances (selective pressures) been different, perhaps the experience of consciousness would be quite different. This is, of course, essentially the same reason why we have difficulty recognising consciousness in other animals (perhaps aliens eventually), even ones we know are highly intelligent.